PTENES中文
implode the box
New ideas about the old (and new) models of advertising film
Society

Anti-Racist Advertising

What I learned in a livestream on anti-racist advertising: why brands still don't represent the people who buy from them, the trap of token casting, and how to tell a genuine campaign from an opportunistic one.

Published Jan 13, 2021 Updated Oct 9, 2026 5 min read
48 reads 0 comments

>>In a hurry?

I took part in a livestream on anti-racist advertising and gathered here the points that stayed with me: consumers now have a voice, representation has grown, but brands still get stuck because there is little diversity inside the companies that create the messages. I talk about "representation by the kilo" in casting, how to tell a genuine campaign from an opportunistic one, and why change depends on who makes the ads, not only on who appears in them.


How many times have you watched an ad and thought "this has nothing to do with me"? Now imagine feeling that your whole life, in almost every commercial break.

The Black movement in Brazil has been saying it for years: if I don't see myself, I don't buy. That was the provocation Paola Prandini, from AfroeducAÇÃO, and Ana Helena, from Instituto ELA Criações Educativas, brought when they invited me to "Diálogos para não passar em branco", a series of conversations critical of whiteness (in Portuguese). Their question for me was: on the production side, do people care about this?

They do. And the conversation was so good that I wanted to share the points that stayed with me. The full video is at the end.

CONSUMERS GOT A VOICE

Not long ago, brands talked and we listened, sitting on the couch watching TV. Social media turned that upside down. Today anyone can comment, criticize, create their own content. A brand can no longer hide from criticism, and that made the concern with being fair grow a lot in advertising production.

The numbers show it. The TODXS study, by the Brazilian agency Heads with UN Women, analyzed commercials on the main TV channels for years: who appeared, who was the lead, which stereotypes kept coming back. From 2015 to 2018, representation grew, and the figure that struck me most was Black women as protagonists, going from almost invisible to close to a quarter of the ads.

SO WHY IS IT STILL SO HARD?

If studies show that people don't feel represented and believe advertising should represent them, and if that would bring audiences closer to brands, why do brands still get stuck?

For me there isn't a single cause, but one weighs a lot: there are too few Black people, women and LGBTQIA+ people inside the companies that plan the communication. Without them, references are missing. And structural racism keeps feeding itself through advertising.

It may sound like an exaggeration. "It's just an ad." But we are surrounded by ads all the time. Besides the product, we consume what they say, symbolically. It stays in our memory and comes back later in choices and attitudes. Often a brand even tries to embrace the topic, but ends up reinforcing racism because it doesn't have the right people, minds and references to build that message.

REPRESENTATION BY THE KILO

Ana mentioned the Brazilian film "Quanto vale ou é por quilo?" ("What Is It Worth?"), by Sérgio Bianchi, and a scene where someone puts an ad together by saying "grab the Indigenous guy, grab the Black guy". I immediately thought of how many pre-production meetings I've seen do exactly that. Casting is done and someone says: "now add one or two Black people".

When that happens, the Black person is cast as a representative of Black people, not as a representative of people. It creates a separation that doesn't exist. Representation isn't an extras quota. It's changing the image we build of the country.

CAN ANTI-RACISM AND PROFIT WALK TOGETHER?

That was the hardest question of the night, and I'm not sure being anti-racist in advertising necessarily means going against a company's profit. In recent years, advertising moved from "selling a product" to talking about values and causes. People love a brand because they identify with what it stands for. A campaign that breaks with the obvious, if it's well made and genuine, stands out among all the ads we skip, and people connect more.

Someone in the audience also made a strong critique: values and causes only enter advertising because they sell, and capital wants money, not equality. I take the warning. That's exactly why the question that matters is not whether a brand talks about a cause, but whether it means it.

HOW TO TELL GENUINE FROM OPPORTUNISTIC

At the time of the livestream, Natura, a big Brazilian cosmetics brand, had just run a Father's Day campaign with Thammy Miranda, a trans man, and his family, and social media turned into a courtroom. For me, just raising the discussion has merit: the conversation reaches the living room, between parents and kids.

But the same movement has another side. During the Black Lives Matter wave, almost every brand took a stand, and many were criticized because they had no history with the topic. Some companies used the discourse while still having enslaved labor in their supply chains. You can't put those two things on the same table. Being anti-racist means being anti-slavery.

The yardstick I use:

  • Continuity. Does the brand talk about this all the time, or only when it's trending?
  • Practice. Does what it does in-house match what it says in the ad?
  • Who builds it. If a campaign about racial and gender equality was made almost only by white men, the brand doesn't really believe in it. It just wants to sell.

ADVERTISING IS MADE BY A LOT OF PEOPLE

There's something we forget when we think of advertising as "the giant brand". Behind every commercial there is a huge network: agency, planning, research, production company, crew, cast. During the pandemic, when everything stopped, we saw how many people were left without work.

That network generates income for many people, including Black people, LGBTQIA+ people and women. That's why, for me, the most important change is in how advertising is built: diverse teams inside companies, agencies and sets, with people from these communities making decisions, not just appearing on screen.

And you, have you seen a campaign that made you think "this is genuine" or "this is opportunism"? Tell me in the comments. This conversation needs to keep going.

Full livestream (in Portuguese):

Watch the video on YouTube

Comments

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Leave a comment

New piece out, straight to your inbox

Get every piece as soon as it is published. No spam, unsubscribe in one click.